
Episode #30
Same Building, Double the Price: The Multifamily Property Insurance Gap
Two multifamily buildings in the same county, matched on size, age, rebuild cost, policy structure and perils, price within 3% of each other at the same carrier. At different carriers, they price about two times apart. The gap is widest inland, not on the coast. St. Louis tops the table at 6.92x, 557 miles from salt water. After 20 years of hurricane modeling, coastal wind is the peril carriers agree on. Hail and severe convective storm are where they don't. In this Data Pulse, Katie walks through trailing twelve months multifamily property data from the Advocate Market Terminal. We cover: How market spread is measured, and why it widens as buildings get more identical Inland territories vs coastal: 4.32x median spread vs 3.34x Observed vs adjusted spread, and why Indianapolis moves the other way Named storm vs severe convective storm as the real driver of carrier disagreement Blanket vs standalone pricing: a structure problem wearing a geography costume Landmark American vs Westchester Surplus: what a tight pricing range actually tells you What the terminal can and can't see, and what a 2x spread really means for your renewal See where your renewal sits against the book: https://advocate.app/?utm_source=spotify&utm_medium=podcast Chapters 0:00 Two identical buildings, double the price 1:09 How we tested market spread 2:29 The spread widens as buildings get more alike 3:35 Where carriers disagree most: inland vs coast 4:28 Observed vs adjusted spread by territory 5:51 Why inland: named storm vs hail and convective storm 7:21 Blanket vs standalone pricing 8:21 Carrier discipline: Landmark American vs Westchester 9:30 Why nobody could see this until now 10:41 Which side of a 2x gap is right? 11:01 Summary Listen on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.

