Episode #60
'Real' Conservative Joins Putnam Race
Republican incumbent calls nominee 'grossly unqualified' A Kent woman who uses her Facebook page to crusade against critical race theory, undocumented immigrants and LGBTQ books in schools is now the Conservative Party's choice to challenge Putnam County Executive Kevin Byrne for his seat. Tatiana Brahimi will replace William Spain Jr. as the Conservative's candidate for county executive in the November election. She will face Byrne, who will have the Republican and Libertarian party lines as he seeks a second 4-year term, and Brett Yarris, who will be on the Democratic and the Working Families lines. Conservatives typically back the same candidate Republicans select, and the party endorsed Byrne when he ran unopposed in 2022. But in March, the Conservative Party announced that it had nominated Spain, its chair and a former county attorney whose brother, Compton Spain, holds the position in the Byrne administration. After Spain was chosen by the Kings County Conservative Party to run for a state judicial seat in Brooklyn, the Putnam Conservatives unanimously backed Brahimi to replace him. The new candidate "best represents the principles and values of our party," said Theresa Votano, the party secretary, on Aug. 14. Those principles included crusading in 2021 against the alleged teaching of critical race theory in the Carmel school district, which landed her appearances on "Fox & Friends" and Newsmax. Posting as Tatiana Ibrahim on Facebook, Brahimi has called for aiding U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement deportation efforts because "if you are here illegally you must go"; described a planned drag show in Carmel as a "pit stop of pedos and groomers"; and labeled Black Lives Matter a "radical racist organization that supports killing cops." Brahimi, whose causes also include "pornographic books" and "Marxist indoctrination" in schools, has dismissed predictions that her campaign will divide Conservatives and Republicans to Yarris' benefit. "For too long, real conservative Republican voters have been told to settle for the same old politics and the same old choices," she said. "Not anymore." Byrne railed against the nomination. In Brahimi, he said, the Conservatives nominated a "grossly unqualified candidate" without interviewing other contenders and giving "principled conservative voters" an opportunity to be heard. "Her erratic conduct and rhetoric are well documented and should concern anyone who expects serious, stable and responsible leadership," he said. Byrne also said the nomination "appears to be the latest effort to split the conservative vote," and suggested that Democrats were involved. He accused Jennifer Colamonico, chair of the Putnam Democratic Committee, of telling Compton Spain he would be re-nominated to be county attorney if he supported Yarris. Colamonico called Byrnes' accusation "demonstrably false." "The myth that somehow Democrats and Conservatives have joined forces to take him down is a fantasy that someone is feeding him, or that he is inventing to make himself feel better," she said. The loss of the Conservative endorsement could be costly for Byrnes. In 2022, the party accounted for 681 of his 5,075 votes, or 13 percent. This year he has an opponent who will bring Democratic voters to the polls. In Putnam, Republicans hold an advantage over Democrats in registered voters, 24,723 to 22,080. But 21,235 voters are unaffiliated, and 2,777 are designated as "other." Of the other parties, 1,689 are Conservative Party members, and 292 belong to the left-leaning Working Families. Hoping to obtain a second ballot line after Conservatives nominated Spain, Byrne joined with three other Republican incumbents — Clerk Michael Bartolotti and coroners John Bourges and Michael Nesheiwat — to collect enough nominating petition signatures to appear on the Libertarian line. They did so over the objections of the Libertarian Party, which endorsed Yarris and said it had never met with Bartolotti, Bourges or Nes...






