
Episode #40
Courtroom Objections Part 3: Who’s Telling the Truth? | Lawyers Without Billboards S2-Ep40
When two people walk into court with completely different versions of what happened, how does a judge decide who to believe? In Part 3 of our courtroom objections series, the Lawyers Without Billboards team tackles character evidence, credibility, relevance, and the rules that determine what a court should and shouldn’t hear. We break down when a witness can testify about someone’s reputation for truthfulness, why specific bad acts usually can’t be used simply to prove bad character, and how cross-examination can sometimes open the door to evidence that otherwise wouldn’t come in. The conversation also covers relevance in family law, including why something that happened years ago may have little bearing on the case today, plus objections involving misstating testimony, assuming facts not in evidence, and questions that aren’t being asked in good faith. Then we get into Rule 403 and the balancing act between evidence that is genuinely probative and evidence that may be unfairly prejudicial, cumulative, confusing, or misleading. Plus, the team shares a few courtroom stories, including gruesome crime-scene evidence, a defendant posing with guns, and why lawyers sometimes need to cross-examine their own clients before anyone ever gets near a c ⏱️ Chapters 00:00 – Welcome to Lawyers Without Billboards 00:41 – The New Georgia Family Law Book 03:53 – Courtroom Objections Part 3 04:20 – Improper Character Evidence 07:01 – When It Becomes a “Swearing Contest” 08:43 – Character Witnesses and Truthfulness 10:05 – Cross-Examining a Character Witness 11:59 – Reputation and the Hearsay Exception 13:06 – What Counts as Relevant Evidence? 14:08 – When Old Misconduct Stops Mattering 16:38 – Why Lawyers Cross-Examine Their Own Clients 17:45 – Legal Advice From Family, Friends…and ChatGPT 20:06 – Misquoting Witnesses and Misstating Evidence 23:15 – Rule 403: Probative Value vs. Unfair Prejudice 24:23 – When Evidence Is Too Prejudicial 27:58 – The “Jesse James” Gun Photo 30:28 – Coming Up: Privilege 31:25 – Closing Subscribe for candid conversations about family law, relationships, and the legal system - without the billboards. ️ Hosts: Steve & Patty Shewmaker, Jimmy & Alexa Lewis Watch here: https://youtu.be/dbctyPG_2m8 or listen on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Google Podcasts, and more. Contact: pshewmaker@shewmakerandlewis.com (770) 939-1939 Website: https://www.shewmakerandlewis.com Podcast Library: https://shewmakerandlewis.com/lawyers-without-billboards Music by Ben Hernandez – Dragonsong Productions Produced by: Bleeding Edge, Inc. Audio & Video Production: Rob Burgner Recorded at: Shewmaker & Lewis, Atlanta, GA #LawyersWithoutBillboards #CourtroomObjections #FamilyLaw #GeorgiaLaw #Evidence #CharacterEvidence #LegalPodcast #TrialLaw #ShewmakerAndLewis






