
Episode #377
Should the Buckeyes Be #1? / Ohio State Primetime LIVE 98 Presented By FanDuel
Ohio State Primetime LIVE 98: Should the Buckeyes Be #1? Hosts: Garrison Gaddy & Riley Burnett | Presented by FanDuel | OhioStateVOCFB Intro (0:31) Welcome to Ohio State Primetime Live. Garrison and Riley recap the usual asks: like/share/subscribe and check vocfb.com/shop for hats, koozies, and tees. Ohio State No. 1 in the Preseason AP Poll (1:03) Ohio State opens the 2026 season ranked No. 1 for the first time since 2015. The Buckeyes received 41 first-place votes. Oregon got 14, Indiana 8, Notre Dame 6, and Miami 1. Georgia received zero. No SEC team earned a first-place vote. Both hosts were surprised. Garrison expected Ohio State at No. 2 or 3 at best. Riley attributed the ranking to overall roster talent, returning production, and the incoming freshman class. They agreed any of the top seven teams could reasonably be argued as No. 1, but winning last year’s championship should not automatically confer the preseason top spot. Other Ranking Thoughts (4:07) Texas A&M at No. 8 is too high. Garrison called himself a “full-blown Texas A&M hater,” citing a soft conference schedule last year and Marcel Reed’s turnover issues. LSU at 11 is boom-or-bust with Lincoln Riley. USC at 14 and Michigan at 16 felt reasonable; Alabama’s drop outside the top 10 (ending a seven-year streak) was understandable given what they have to prove. Back half of the poll: SMU 19, Tennessee 20, Iowa 22, Louisville 24. They’ll be cheering for Louisville. Ohio State’s Daunting Schedule (8:36) The official slate starts with No. 1 Ohio State at No. 5 Texas in Week 2 (night game, 6:30 p.m. local). Both teams get a Week 1 tune-up first (Ohio State vs. Ball State at home). Texas camp reports (via Boog and others) described Arch Manning still missing throws, two interceptions in a scrimmage, and a Ryan Wingo drop. Garrison still likes Ohio State by at least a touchdown. Later notable games: Illinois (Illibuck rivalry) At No. 22 Iowa (tough venue, possible night game; they recalled Oregon’s struggles there last year) Maryland (homecoming) At No. 6 Indiana At USC (starting center lost for the season; backup has never taken a snap at the position) Ohio State is currently a 1.5-point underdog at Texas (total 47.5). Hosts like the number and expect to know the over/under fate by the end of the first quarter. Ranking the Six Ranked Matchups by Importance (16:16) Garrison (most to least important): Oregon Michigan Indiana Texas USC Iowa He called the Oregon game the biggest for the Big Ten and the national landscape. Riley: Iowa 6th (talent gap at skill positions), Texas next (non-conference road night game), then USC, Indiana (revenge for last year’s Big Ten title game), Michigan (heart over head), Oregon as the biggest conference/national game. Four of the six are on the road. They agreed the Michigan game remains “the game” inside the programs but Oregon carries more weight on a larger scale. Chris Canty’s Miami Triplets Take (22:29) Canty argued Miami’s QB-RB-WR trio (Darian Mensah, Mark Fletcher, Malachi Toney) is better than Ohio State’s (Julian Sayin, Bo Jackson, Jeremiah Smith). Hosts rejected it strongly: Jeremiah Smith is not comparable to Toney (X vs. slot; significant talent gap). Sayin is a far better decision-maker than Mensah. Bo Jackson outproduced Fletcher on fewer carries (6.1 ypc vs. 5.5) and is a better receiving back. Jackson also had a 22-carry game vs. Michigan, something neither Quinshon Judkins nor TreVeyon Henderson did the year before. Volume stats favor Miami because Duke/Miami played from behind more often. They called the comparison unfair and said Canty was “dead wrong.” Senior Day Moved Off Michigan Week (33:13) Ryan Day shifted Senior Day so the team can focus more on the Michigan game. Garrison (former player) said he doesn’t care about the 45-minute pregame hugs when players should be locked in. Both believe every senior would rather beat Michigan than take the photo. Riley noted this follows last year’s decision to move the band/CJ Stroud video out of Michigan week. AP Preseason All-America Teams (39:38) They walked through the first team: QB: Dante Moore (no issue) RBs: Kwion Lacy and Ahmad Hardy (Hardy the best back in the country) OL: Carter Smith (Indiana) as the top lineman; no Ohio State players TE: Trey’Dez Green (LSU) — they preferred Oregon’s Jefferson WRs: Jeremiah Smith (lock), Malachi Toney, Cam Coleman Edges: Colin Simmons and Dylan Stewart (both still have to prove it) LBs: Rasheem Biles, Xavier Atkins, Elijah Hardy (Indiana — best LB in the country) CBs: Leonard Moore and Ellis Robinson IV (hosts prefer Brandon Finney) Safeties: K.J. Bolden and Corey Persh (Jalen McClain close) Overall grade: B+/A-. Athletic Coaching Tiers (48:11) Chris Benigni’s 2026 coaching tiers placed Ryan Day in Tier 2. Hosts were furious. They argued Day belongs in Tier 1 given his win percentage and recent championship. They ripped the placements of Sarkisian, James Franklin, Kalen DeBoer, Dabo Swinney, and others, saying no consistent logic (trophy case or recency) holds the list together. Outro (54:48) Thanks for watching. Shows typically air Tuesdays at 7 p.m. ET plus the Thursday call-in with Denzel. O-H… I-O. Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

