
Episode #53
Gary Stump on Faith Through Loss, Biblical Prophecy, Israel, and Building a Legacy
In this episode of Risk & Resolve , Ben Conner and Todd Hufford sit down with longtime pastor and mentor Gary Stump . Gary shares the life-changing story of losing his first wife, Donna, in a tragic car accident, the question from God that reshaped his understanding of trust, and how suffering ultimately led him into pastoral ministry. The conversation also explores Gary’s theological perspective on Israel, biblical prophecy, the church, and the importance of passing faith and leadership to the next generation. Main Talking Points: Growing up in Indianapolis and Brown County, Indiana Starting his career in the life insurance business alongside his father Meeting Pete John and discovering a personal relationship with Jesus How studying Scripture began transforming Gary’s marriage and family The devastating car accident that took the life of his wife, Donna The question that changed his life: “Do you really trust me? Or do you just say you trust me?” Wrestling with grief while raising four young children Becoming a student of the Book of Job during his darkest season The Charles Stanley message that challenged him not to “waste” his suffering Moving from asking “Why?” in accusation to seeking purpose through suffering How grief ultimately became part of Gary’s call into pastoral ministry Meeting Kathy and watching God rebuild his family The influence of Pete John and Malcolm Nabel on Gary’s faith and theology Gary’s theological perspective on Israel and the Jewish people His interpretation of biblical prophecy, the church, the tribulation, and the future of Israel Why he believes Christians can support Israel while still disagreeing with actions of its government The influence of visiting Israel and studying the Jewish foundations of Christianity Preserving Pete John’s Bible and the legacy of the people Pete led to faith Leaving his former church in 2011 without knowing what would come next Stepping out in faith and eventually founding Onward Church Gary’s desire to write books and identify the next-generation leader for his congregation The importance of passing faith, leadership, and stewardship to the generation behind you

