
Episode #197
Grading Texas' Win Over Tennessee
TexasVOCFB — Grading Texas’ Win Over Tennessee Hosts: Matthew Miller & Thomas Bresee Special edition / postgame grades Texas 4-0 after a road win at Neyland Stadium Intro (0:00–0:10) Welcome to a special grading show on Texas’ win over Tennessee. Like/subscribe plug, then they jump straight into unit grades. Quarterback — Arch Manning Grades: C+ / C+ Same grade as last week; that’s the season-long grade for Manning so far. Good enough to beat Tennessee and similar remaining teams; not good enough to win elite games consistently. Pocket presence still needs work — that was the one off day. Accuracy was solid; almost no complete misses. Two plays where he crossed the line of scrimmage and still threw (indecision). Cleaned it up later. First drive is the template they want most of the time, especially once the OL has more cohesion in November. A lot of the night was out of his hands. Not terrible, but he has to be better going forward. Running Backs Grades: B- / B- Hardest unit to grade — they didn’t get many lanes. Relique Brown was the main guy. Ran hard. One highlight: hopped, spun, dodged a tackle for 7–8 yards (would have been 1–2 last year) and helped set up a first down later. Ugly 3–4 yard runs when needed. Hollywood Smothers would have helped find extra yards; he’s out. Derek Cooper still a bit banged up as a freshman. Poor blocking around them. Performed pretty well down the stretch given the circumstances. Wide Receivers Grades: C+ / B- No dropped passes. Cam Coleman one really good catch. Ryan Wingo a couple of late plays. Emmitt Mosley one early catch, then nothing. Host 1: same C+ as Manning — solid, doing their jobs, nothing special. Explosive plays have to start showing up if Texas is going to jump. Host 2: bumps to B- because Wingo was exceptional — YAC, screen where he made guys miss and fought for a first down, plus a great block on Relique Brown’s first TD. Coleman’s one big play; wanted more on the deep ball (looked like he got tripped). Need more volume from Coleman on that type of play. Tight Ends Grades: C / C Almost an incomplete — one catch, barely involved. Blocking wasn’t as good as usual, but hard to isolate when the OL struggled. Nothing they did prevented good things; they were part of the same non-rhythm as the rest of the offense. Worst blocking performance of the season. Nick Townsend’s absence is felt — most complete player in the room. Amari Winston is talented but not the same blocker or as comfortable in the offense yet. Group is still talented; Townsend makes it whole. Offensive Line Grades: D- / C- (worst of the year) Host 1’s worst grade of the night. Connor Robertson and Brandon Baker had many bad plays. Robertson is a liability vs. athletic interior guys (same issue vs. Ohio State’s Kerry Wilder / Gilliam types). Baker: assignment/communication issues — one play he stood between two defenders and blocked neither, nearly got Manning killed. If grading individuals: Robertson and Baker F, rest maybe C+. Unit as a whole D-. Host 2: C- (initially said C+). Worst performance of the year by a comfortable margin. Fourth-quarter drive when they had to just run it was decent. Putting Jackson Christian in doesn’t fix the athleticism problem. Baker getting more confident and communicating better at guard is the more realistic fix. Still working out how they play together, especially on the road. Not overly worried long-term, but this can’t happen vs. Ole Miss or LSU. Tennessee’s DL is better than average on the remaining schedule (Oklahoma better if David Stone is healthy; Florida another tough one). Bye week to get communication and plan right. 4-0 now; can figure it out. Defensive Line Grades: A+ / A+ (better than A+) 10 sacks and they stopped the run. Nothing else to discuss. Every player was incredible. Murad Watson awesome. Zeno Mozilo didn’t show up much on the stat sheet but was great. Lance Jackson no sack but felt like three. Alex January and Hiro Kanu both in on sacks. No Justice Terry and they still did this. Terry is the highest-ceiling DT; this is what the unit can be — take over games even when offense and other units have issues. Colin Simmons: already 8 (or 9) sacks on the season. Preseason over/under was 4.5. Quick start this year vs. last year’s late surge. UTSA and Texas State already changed game plans because of him. Teams will keep doing that. Penalty (fake Johnson celebration) — if you get five sacks you should be allowed to do whatever as long as you don’t touch anyone. He understood it was wrong, put it behind him, and kept playing. No one has to police him. Linebackers Grades: A / A Justin Krier a little quiet. Raheem Biles not quiet — insane closing speed when spying Faison Brandon, sack, a couple TFLs. Fun player. Richie Miles: 13 tackles + late sack (huge). Krier second with 9 tackles + late PBU that was almost a pick. Unit they were worried about coming into the year. Depth still a question, but Kosiak-Paula made special-teams plays. Brad Spence is B+ or better whenever he’s on the field. Younger guys should get more run later. Secondary Grades: B- / B+ Tricky. Good at times, picked on at others. A couple PIs. Weird TD where Bo Masco didn’t realize what was happening. Front was so disruptive that Brandon didn’t see a lot of open guys. Host 2: B+ because of how much that offense spreads the secondary and puts guys on islands. Masco didn’t look like the veteran. Grayson Littleton one of the best players on the team. Cade Phillips still improving. Jelani McDonald all over the field and made the play that sealed it. Kobe Black played (3 tackles) but Derek Williams Jr. was more visible (5 tackles) and is playing better football. Black may still be limited. Coaching Grades: B / B- Sark a little robotic on first down (too many handoffs). Play-calling overall good when the OL held up. Defense excellent. Special teams good. Execution lagged behind some of the calls. Penalties fall on coaches (Simmons one they let him wear). Have to clean them up a bit even if SEC play won’t be perfect. First drive worked; then OL collapsed and they had to adjust on the fly — not easy. Give Sark some leeway. Will Muschamp is a top-5 defensive mind right now; the change from Pete Kwiatkowski to Muschamp is paying off. One complaint: don’t go prevent when you’re dominating and up multiple scores. Let the guys pin their ears back and make the freshman QB more uncomfortable. This team is better when it attacks (same lesson as first half vs. Ohio State last year). Conservative isn’t their personality. Big-picture / looking ahead Walked into what they consider the second-toughest place to play in the country. Neyland was packed from the jump. Found a way to win, now 4-0 heading into the bye, then a 2-2 Oklahoma team that’s reeling. Feels like the reverse of last year (Texas undefeated, Oklahoma 2-2 then). Don’t do what they did today (shoot themselves in the foot with OL/penalties) and Oklahoma probably can’t beat them. Same game plan next week: make John Mateer beat you. Don’t think he’s capable. Oklahoma OL is also attackable. Manning feels closer to being in a groove; pieces are starting to come together. Needs the OL to get there so he can play full-time clean football. Tuesday 7 p.m. ET: one-third-of-the-season recap, look-ahead, Oklahoma talk, any breaking news. Quick grade card (both hosts) Unit Host 1 Host 2 QB C+ C+ RBs B- B- WRs C+ B- TEs C C OL D- C- DL A+ A+ LBs A A Secondary B- B+ Coaching B B- Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

