
Episode #49
Long-Term & Short-Term Property Management: Two Completely Different Businesses | Declan McGonigal
In this episode of Unfiltered, Dylan Scroggins talks with Declan McGonigal, CEO of myBeach Vacation Rentals in Myrtle Beach, South Carolina, about building a property management business across both the long-term and short-term rental markets. Declan shares how he got into property management, grew his vacation rental portfolio from just a handful of properties to more than 80, and later acquired a long-term management company that now manages around 285 properties. He explains why the two sides of the business operate with completely different teams, technology, and day-to-day demands. They also dive into the realities of running a highly seasonal short-term rental market, the challenges of relying on platforms like Airbnb, and why property managers need to turn platform guests into direct customers. Declan breaks down when short-term rentals can be a strong revenue opportunity, when the investment may not be worth it, and what owners need to consider before converting a property. The conversation also explores AI, including where Declan is already seeing meaningful results, why short-term rentals are harder to automate, and why chasing every new AI tool can become a distraction from the biggest bottleneck in your business. Links Declan on LinkedIn - / Declan McGonigal | LinkedIn Dylan on LinkedIn - / Dylan Scroggins | LinkedIn Matt on LinkedIn - / Matt Speer | LinkedIn PropertyManagement.com - https://propertymanagement.com/ The Kalmar Group - https://thekalmargroup.com/pm Subscribe to PropertyManagement.com's weekly Newsletter: https://propertymanagement-com.kit.com/subscribe-to-newsletter Chapters 01:50β03:58 β From Engineering to 80+ Vacation Rentals 05:34β06:35 β The Airbnb Dependency Problem 07:16β09:14 β Why Airbnb and Zillow Want to Own the Customer 09:43β12:14 β Short-Term vs. Long-Term: Two Different Ball Games 12:33β13:16 β Why Property Managers Love College Guests 19:09β20:59 β When a $1.5M Property Isn't Worth Going Short-Term 22:42β24:23 β Why AI Is Easier to Implement in Long-Term Rentals 25:00β26:09 β AI Can Be a Great Distraction 26:57β30:36 β How Property Management Changed Declan 32:18β32:36 β The Future of Property Management: "Disrupted" Disclaimer: The content of this podcast is for informational purposes only and does not constitute professional advice. Always perform your own due diligence before making any financial or business decisions.






